Monthly Archives: November 2013

Frustrations

Working on my Public History Project. I’m now more intimately aware with the development of Landers, Frary, & Clark’s Universal Coffee Percolator then perhaps any one person need be. Just trying to figure out what to do with this information now and coming to the frightening conclusion that I have not a clue.

Leave a comment

Filed under Assignments

Dying of Thrist in an Ocean of Knowledge

Dan Cohen is revisited this week, though instead of a rallying cry to produce more content online as he did in his blog post advocating for more historical scholars to create blogs of their own, which I discussed here, he is now commenting on the seemingly over abundance of information that can not be easily sorted through in the majority of  historical databases available now. He compares this phenomenon to the reality described in the short story “The Library of Babel”, which is about a library containing books filled with all the words in the world combined in every way possible, but no way of knowing what contains what. The inhabitants of this world are destined to search the library through books of gibberish, hoping that eventually they will find something containing some meaning to it.

Needless to say this comparison of a fruitless search through an endless library of meaningless books to historical databases is a bit unsettling, though not without merit. In my time as a history major I can attest to the frustration of searching through countless library databases trying to find something of relevance, desperately trying to think of the specific combination of search words that will not bring up hundreds of links to something which only mention your desired topic in passing, or the same search terms being used in an article completely unrelated before shouting at your computer screen “No I did not want to know about French domestic life! I need something on Ottoman Coffee-houses!”, needless to say, the struggle is real.

Cohen proposes to help alleviate some of the problems attributed to trying to find related primary sources and scholarly writings on a specific subject my introducing an API format of searching, similar to the ones that Google and Yahoo both use. Cohen argues the success of this style, however he also notes that it’s not exactly a cost effective approach, stating that Google and Yahoo use it because they are both in the commercial sectors. Though this may be the case, both Cohen and I, as well as perhaps anyone who’s ever used a clunky search engine based Historical database, would say that the benefits far outweigh the costs.

 

Leave a comment

Filed under Assignments

Spacial History? What, like the History of Space?

When first reading Richard White’s post on spacial history, and the enormous undertaking it is to accomplish, I was a bit confused. I had never heard of it before, which really was a shame because it is such a massive project, that you would think there would be a bit more of a buzz about it in History courses. Spacial history operates with the idea that space is not based on natural geography, nor is it simply a vacuum in which history happens in, but something that humanity produces itself. It seems a very heady concept to grasp, but to put it simply it is the study of the history of space, and what influences it, politically, culturally, economically, ect. The spacial history project is a way of mapping these events and occurrences, happening over the course of human existence, and to say that this is a substantial task seems to be somewhat of a gross understatement. Richard explains that there are multiple people working on it from all over the world, and its easy to think that this type of collaborative mass project would not be possible without the advent of the internet age. Even while reading the description, I was sort of reminded of Wikipedia, in that that too is a massive bank of constantly growing information, except with the Spacial History Project, you don’t have the additional hazard of the unreliable contributor nearly as often as on Wikipedia. It is an overall fascinating take on transforming the way historians are looking at history and I’m very excited for the continuing development of the project.

Interested in reading more? Read White’s article for yourself

Leave a comment

Filed under Assignments